One bite and you’re right back home.
Our handcrafted peanut butter cookies deliver that rich, nostalgic flavor you remember — golden edges, delicate cracks, and the classic criss-cross pattern pressed into every cookie.
We bake them fresh in small batches from scratch at Sips & Sweets. No pre-made dough, no shortcuts. Just real ingredients and homemade care in every batch.
The Scratch-Made Difference We make our own vanilla for a warm, deep flavor that store-bought can’t touch. We even create our own brown sugar by blending granulated sugar with rich molasses. That homemade brown sugar brings extra moisture, subtle caramel notes, and the perfect texture that pairs so well with peanut butter.
Each cookie is carefully shaped by hand and double-pressed with a fork to create that signature criss-cross design — a simple touch that makes them unmistakably homemade.
Rustic, Golden & Proudly Homemade These cookies aren’t meant to look perfect or factory-made — and we wouldn’t have it any other way. Every one has its own rustic shape, beautiful golden color, and generous size, full of real peanut butter flavor.
They’re the kind of cookies that feel comforting and a little bit special. Perfect with a cold glass of milk, your morning coffee, or enjoyed while you wander the market.
Find Them at Our Local Markets We’ll be bringing these fresh peanut butter cookies — along with our breads, cinnamon rolls, and other Sips & Sweets favorites — to select local markets. Each cookie is individually packaged and ready to take home or share.
Because everything is made by hand in small batches, quantities are limited. Arrive early for the best selection!
Follow Sips & Sweets for upcoming market dates and fresh-from-the-oven updates. We can’t wait to bake something sweet for you.